The Most Stolen Cars of 2025, and How to Avoid Buying One on Marketplace
Here's the good news: vehicle theft in the U.S. is falling fast. The bad news: about 660,000 cars were still stolen last year, and some of them get resold to unsuspecting buyers through private-sale apps. If you buy a stolen car, you can lose both the car and the money you paid. Here's what to know.
Thefts are at multi-decade lows: The National Insurance Crime Bureau counted 659,880 vehicle thefts in 2025, down 23% from 2024 and among the lowest levels in several decades [1]. The decline continued into 2026: 268,415 thefts in the first half of the year, down about 21%, with all 50 states falling [2]. California (136,988), Texas (75,269) and Illinois (28,327) had the most thefts in 2025 [1].
The most stolen models of 2025: According to NICB, the most stolen vehicles were the Hyundai Elantra (21,732), Honda Accord (17,797), Hyundai Sonata (17,687), Chevrolet Silverado 1500 (16,764), Honda Civic (12,725), Kia Optima (11,521), Ford F-150 (10,102), Toyota Camry (9,833), Honda CR-V (9,809) and Nissan Altima (8,445) [3]. Many of these are also among the most popular used cars on Marketplace, which is why buyers need to check carefully.
The Hyundai/Kia wave is fading: Hyundai and Kia made up 14% of all thefts in 2025, down from 16% in 2024 and 21% in 2023, as software updates and anti-theft measures took effect [3]. In January 2026, the automakers agreed to a $9 million settlement with 36 state attorneys general covering 2015–2021 Hyundais and 2011–2021 Kias with turn-key ignitions, including ignition-cylinder protectors and software upgrades [4]. If you're buying one of these models, ask whether the anti-theft update has been done.
How stolen cars get resold: Title washing and VIN cloning. The Department of Justice's NMVTIS program explains that branded titles can be "washed" by retitling a vehicle in a state that doesn't check with the state that branded it [5]. Florida's highway safety department describes VIN cloning as a scheme in which a stolen car gets the VIN of a legitimate one, with counterfeit VIN tags and fake documents [6]. NICB has documented stolen, VIN-switched vehicles sold on apps like OfferUp below market value with fake VIN plates and phony titles [7].
Check 1: Run the VIN. Get a National Motor Vehicle Title Information System (NMVTIS) report, which covers title, odometer and certain damage history and costs up to $4 per report. NMVTIS also points buyers to NICB's free VIN database for theft and total-loss records [8]. Pair those with a commercial vehicle history report.
Check 2: Match every VIN. Compare the VIN on the dashboard plate, the driver's door jamb sticker and the title. They must match exactly. Florida HSMV advises inspecting the dashboard VIN plate for signs of tampering and checking the title for misspellings or irregularities [6].
Check 3: Question the paperwork and the price. Be wary of a late-model car with no lienholder, a seller whose name doesn't match the title, or a price far below comparable cars [6]. NICB's advice: meet at a police station, run the VIN, have authorities verify the title and VIN before you pay, and walk away if the price is unrealistically low [7].
Check 4: Get an inspection. NMVTIS strongly encourages buyers to get an independent inspection along with a title report [8]. A mechanic will spot replaced VIN plates, damaged ignitions and other signs of theft that are easy to miss.
Where Deelz helps: Being first to a good listing is how you win on Marketplace. Being first to a stolen one is how you lose. Deelz emails you matching cars as it finds them, which gives you time to run the VIN, check the title and set up a safe meeting before you commit.
Bottom line: Car theft is falling, but it's not gone, and the most stolen models are some of the most popular used cars. Run the VIN, match every number, question deals that are too good to be true, and never pay before the paperwork checks out.
Sources
- [1]U.S. vehicle thefts experience historic decline (NICB 2025 data) — Carrier Management (Mar 2026)
- [2]Vehicle thefts down about 21% in first half of 2026 (NICB) — Carrier Management (Oct 2026)
- [3]NICB: most stolen vehicles of 2025 — Insurance Journal (Mar 2026)
- [4]Hyundai and Kia dish out another settlement over theft epidemic — ClickOrlando (Jan 2026)
- [5]What is NMVTIS? — U.S. Department of Justice, Bureau of Justice Assistance
- [6]Vehicle Cloning — Florida Highway Safety and Motor Vehicles
- [7]NICB recaps how scammers use apps to swindle used-vehicle buyers — Auto Remarketing (2018)
- [8]NMVTIS Buying Tips — U.S. Department of Justice, Bureau of Justice Assistance
