Holiday Marketplace Scams to Watch in 2026 (and How to Spot Them)
The holidays are the busiest time of year on Facebook Marketplace, Craigslist and OfferUp, and the busiest for scammers too. Last year's numbers set records. The FBI's Internet Crime Complaint Center logged $20.9 billion in reported losses in 2025, 26% more than in 2024 [1], and the FTC received 3 million fraud reports totaling $15.9 billion [2].
Where the scams start: Social media. Reported losses to scams that started there reached $2.1 billion in 2025, about eight times the 2020 figure. Shopping scams were the most reported type, and Facebook had the most reported losses of any platform [3]. The Better Business Bureau's numbers agree: online purchase scams were 28.4% of all reports to BBB Scam Tracker in 2025, and 89.3% of people targeted lost money [4]. Cars and machinery were among the three product categories named most often [4].
Scam #1 — The fake payment screenshot. A buyer says they've paid and sends a screenshot, or an email that looks like it came from Zelle or Venmo. Meta lists both tactics on its Marketplace scam page [5]. The rule is simple: money isn't real until you see it inside your own banking or payment app. Never trust a screenshot or an email.
Scam #2 — The overpayment refund. A buyer "accidentally" sends too much and asks you to refund the difference. The original payment later reverses, and the refund you sent is gone. Meta flags this one by name [5]. If someone overpays, don't refund anything until the full amount has cleared, and preferably just cancel the deal.
Scam #3 — The verification code request. A "buyer" asks you to read back a code sent to your phone, supposedly to prove you're real. That code is usually setting up an account in your name, such as a Google Voice number [5]. Nobody legitimate needs a code that was sent to your phone.
Scam #4 — The deposit on a car you haven't seen. The car is underpriced, the seller is "out of state," and a deposit will hold it. Meta's advice is direct: don't send deposits for high-value items like cars until you've confirmed they're real, for example by seeing the title (the pink slip) in person or on a live video call [5].
Scam #5 — AI-polished listings and sellers. Bad grammar used to be the giveaway. Not anymore. The FBI warns that criminals use generative AI to make realistic profile photos, forged IDs, cloned voices and deepfake video calls [6]. 2025 was the first year the FBI tracked AI-related complaints: 22,364 of them, with $893 million in losses [1]. BBB also saw a notable rise in reports mentioning AI, mostly in online purchase scams [4]. Polished photos and perfect messages no longer prove anything.
How to pay (and get paid) safely: Treat Zelle like cash. Chase's guidance is to only send money with Zelle to people you know and trust, because once a payment is sent it's usually final [7]. The FTC recommends paying by credit card where you can, and says anyone demanding gift cards, wire transfers, payment apps or crypto is probably running a scam [8]. For local deals, meet somewhere public, inspect the item first, and pay at the handoff.
Your pre-deal checklist: (1) Search the seller's name plus "scam" or "review" [8]. (2) Confirm any payment inside your own app, never from a screenshot. (3) Never share a verification code. (4) No deposits on cars or other big-ticket items you haven't seen in person. (5) For vehicles, match the VIN on the title, the dashboard and the door jamb. (6) If the price is far below market and the seller is in a hurry, slow down.
Fast doesn't mean reckless: Being first to a great listing is how you win on Marketplace, but the point of being first is having time to check things properly. Deelz emails you new matches as soon as it finds them, so you can move quickly and still leave yourself time to check the seller and the item.
Bottom line: The scams are getting more convincing, but they still depend on the same few moves: fake proof of payment, pressure to pay first, and payment methods you can't undo. Learn to spot those three and you're safer than most buyers on the platform.
Sources
- [1]2025 Internet Crime Report — FBI Internet Crime Complaint Center (IC3)
- [2]Testimony on the Rising Scam Economy, Joint Economic Committee (March 25, 2026) — Federal Trade Commission
- [3]Reported losses to scams on social media eight times higher than 2020 — FTC Data Spotlight (April 2026)
- [4]2025 BBB Scam Tracker Risk Report — BBB Institute for Marketplace Trust
- [5]About scams on Facebook Marketplace — Meta Help Center
- [6]Criminals Use Generative Artificial Intelligence to Facilitate Financial Fraud (PSA I-120324-PSA) — FBI IC3
- [7]Use Zelle safely — Chase
- [8]How to avoid an online shopping scam this holiday season — FTC Consumer Alert (Nov 2025)
