Deelz
    Back to Blog
    Strategy

    The Post-Holiday Resale Wave: What to Buy Secondhand in December & January

    Nov 15, 20266 min read

    Every January a wave of lightly used stuff hits Facebook Marketplace, Craigslist and OfferUp: duplicate gifts, upgraded-from electronics, the tool nobody asked for. If you know it's coming, it's one of the best buying windows of the year.

    A record season means a big wave: The National Retail Federation forecasts that 2026 holiday sales (November and December) will grow 4.2% to $1.013 trillion, up from $972 billion in 2025 [1]. Retailers also expected 17% of 2025 holiday sales to be returned [2]. That's a lot of merchandise changing hands, and not all of it goes back to the store.

    Plenty of gifts don't go back: In a CouponFollow survey taken in January 2026, 22% of U.S. adults had already returned an unwanted holiday gift and another 10% planned to. Respondents had an average of about two unwanted gifts worth $143, and 57% said they've regifted rather than returned something [3]. Items past the return window, or bought without a receipt, often end up listed for sale.

    Selling secondhand is mainstream now: OfferUp's 2026 Recommerce Report puts the U.S. recommerce market at $246.7 billion in 2026. Half of U.S. adults (51%) sold something secondhand in the past year, and about three-quarters of secondhand spending is outside clothing: furniture, electronics, home improvement and more [4]. eBay's 2026 Recommerce Report found 76% of consumers bought secondhand in the past year, and 84% count saving money among their top three reasons [5]. ThredUp's 2026 report found 57% of shoppers resell items for income [6]. More sellers means more listings, and more motivated people listing in January to pay off December.

    What to target: Electronics lose value fastest, so a lightly used one is where the discount is. Back Market says older iPhones typically lose 15–20% of their value when a new model launches, and that the iPhone 15 series lost more than half its value within 12 months [7]. Phones, tablets, headphones, game consoles and smartwatches that were opened and barely used are the sweet spot. Power tools and small kitchen appliances are another common category for duplicate gifts.

    How to time it: The first two weeks of January are when you'll see the most "opened but never used" listings, as people clear out after the holidays and look for cash. Listings priced to move go fast, often within hours in a busy metro. Set your searches up in December so you're already watching when the wave starts.

    How to buy safely: (1) For electronics, check that the device is signed out of the seller's account (Apple ID / Google account) and not carrier-locked. (2) Ask for the original box and receipt. It suggests the item isn't stolen and may carry warranty coverage. (3) Test it in person before you pay. (4) Pay at the handoff, in a public place, and avoid payment methods you can't reverse.

    Where Deelz helps: Set alerts like "PS5 under $300" or "AirPods Pro under $120" across Facebook Marketplace, Craigslist and OfferUp. When someone lists the duplicate gift they want gone by the weekend, Deelz emails you as soon as it finds the listing.

    Bottom line: A trillion-dollar holiday season turns into a January resale wave. Know what you want, set your price targets before New Year's, and be the first message when the good listings go up.

    Sources

    1. [1]NRF Forecasts 2026 Holiday Sales Growth as Consumers Remain Resilient — National Retail Federation (Oct 2026)
    2. [2]Consumers Expected to Return Nearly $850 Billion in Merchandise in 2025 — National Retail Federation & Happy Returns (Oct 2025)
    3. [3]Unwrapped and Unwanted: Holiday Gift Return Trends — CouponFollow (Jan 2026)
    4. [4]OfferUp 2026 Recommerce Report coverage — Just Style (Oct 2026)
    5. [5]eBay 2026 Recommerce Report — Value Added Resource (Oct 2026)
    6. [6]ThredUp Resale Report 2026 — ThredUp (Apr 2026)
    7. [7]iPhone trade-in value — Back Market

    Stop missing deals

    Get alerts the moment matching cars are posted.

    Start free