How Auto Tariffs Changed Used Car and Repair Costs in 2026
The auto tariffs announced in spring 2025 were supposed to reshape car prices. A year and a half later, the picture is more nuanced than the headlines suggested. Used car prices spiked briefly, then settled. The longer-lasting impact is showing up in new-car prices and in what it costs to fix the car you already have.
What the tariffs are: A 25% Section 232 tariff on imported cars and light trucks took effect on April 3, 2025, and imported auto parts followed on May 3, 2025 [1]. Many exceptions have been added since. Parts that comply with the US-Mexico-Canada Agreement (USMCA) are exempt, USMCA vehicles pay only on their non-U.S. content, most UK cars pay 10%, and cars from the EU, Japan and South Korea pay 15% [2]. In October 2025 the tariffs were extended to medium- and heavy-duty trucks (25%) and buses (10%) [3]. A February 2026 Supreme Court ruling struck down tariffs imposed under emergency powers (IEEPA), but it didn't touch the Section 232 auto tariffs [4].
The used-price spike: The clearest effect came right away. In April 2025, the Manheim index of wholesale used-car prices jumped 2.7% in a single month, and Cox Automotive said values rose sharply on the back of the tariff announcement as buyers rushed to get ahead of expected increases [5].
Then things settled: By October 2026, wholesale used prices were up just 2.0% year over year (seasonally adjusted), and Cox described October as typically the weakest month of the year [6]. In other words, the tariff rush faded, and the used market is now driven by ordinary supply and demand, not tariff panic.
Where the cost went instead: New cars. Cox estimates the tariffs cost automakers and suppliers about $35 billion in 2025, with roughly $3,800 per vehicle absorbed rather than passed on. In 2026 automakers are passing more of it to buyers through higher MSRPs, higher destination fees, fewer standard features and smaller incentives [7]. The average new-vehicle transaction price hit a record $51,109 in October 2026 [8]. When new cars cost more, more shoppers look at used cars, which keeps used prices firm.
Repairs got more expensive: This is where most car owners feel it. Average part prices in the collision-repair market were about 8% higher year over year in early 2026, a rise CCC Intelligent Solutions called generally aligned with tariff activity [9]. In federal price data, vehicle maintenance and repair costs were up 5.8% year over year in September 2026 [10]. Back in 2025, the American Property Casualty Insurance Association projected that a 25% tariff on imported repair parts could add about $3.4 billion to personal auto premiums [11]. So far, insurance prices haven't followed: the motor vehicle insurance index was actually down 5.0% year over year in September [10].
What this means for used-car buyers: (1) Price in maintenance. Repairs and parts cost more than they did two years ago, so a cheaper car that needs work may no longer be the bargain it looks like. (2) Get a pre-purchase inspection so you know what's coming. (3) Favor cars with good parts availability and reliability records. (4) Don't buy in a panic. The 2025 rush showed how quickly fear can push prices up, and how quickly they settle back.
Where Deelz helps: When everyone's watching headlines, the advantage goes to buyers watching listings. Deelz emails you when a car matching your search and price range turns up on Facebook Marketplace, Craigslist or OfferUp, so you can act on the real price of a real car, not the forecast.
Bottom line: The tariffs moved used prices briefly. They've moved new-car prices and repair costs for much longer. For used-car buyers in late 2026, the smart move is to budget for maintenance, inspect carefully, and grab well-priced listings fast.
Sources
- [1]Section 232 Tariffs on Automobiles and Automobile Parts — timeline — Sandler, Travis & Rosenberg
- [2]Section 232 Automotive Tariffs: Issues for Congress (IN12545) — Congressional Research Service (May 2026)
- [3]Fact Sheet: Imports of Medium- and Heavy-Duty Vehicles, Parts and Buses — The White House (Oct 2025)
- [4]Learning Resources v. Trump: Supreme Court ruling on IEEPA tariffs (LSB11398) — Congressional Research Service (Feb 2026)
- [5]Manheim Used Vehicle Value Index: April 2025 — Cox Automotive (May 2025)
- [6]Manheim Used Vehicle Value Index: October 2026 Trends — Cox Automotive (Nov 2026)
- [7]Q1 2026 Industry Insights and Sales Forecast (presentation) — Cox Automotive (Mar 2026)
- [8]Average Transaction Price Report: October 2026 — Cox Automotive / Kelley Blue Book (Nov 2026)
- [9]CCC mid-year collision repair trends update — Repairer Driven News (Oct 2026)
- [10]Consumer Price Index — September 2026 — U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics
- [11]Auto parts tariffs could raise repair claim costs, APCIA says — Claims Journal (Jun 2025)
