What to Look For in a Used Car Listing (Before You Message the Seller)
Short answer: Before you message a seller, check five things in the listing: the photos, the description, the title status, the price compared with similar cars, and whether the VIN is shown or offered. A good listing has many clear photos, specific maintenance details, a clean title in the seller's name, and a price that makes sense for the market. Anything missing is a question to ask before you drive out.
1. The photos: Serious sellers show the car from every angle, plus the interior, the dashboard with the engine running, the tires and the engine bay. A handful of blurry or cropped photos isn't proof of a problem, but ask for more. Look for mismatched paint between panels, uneven gaps, and tires worn more on one edge, which can point to alignment or suspension problems. Check that the photos look like they were taken in the same place; photos copied from elsewhere are a common scam tactic.
2. The description: Specific details are a good sign. "New brakes and tires last spring, timing belt at 90k, records available" tells you far more than "runs great." Look for a reason for selling, mileage, number of owners and any known issues. Honest disclosure of small problems is usually a better sign than a description that claims the car is perfect.
3. Title status: Look for the words salvage, rebuilt, flood or lien. A salvage title means an insurer declared the car a total loss. Some listings don't mention title status at all, so ask directly, and ask whether the title is in the seller's name.
4. Price versus the market: Compare the price with similar cars nearby, on more than one marketplace, and with a pricing guide such as Kelley Blue Book or Edmunds. A price well below everything else isn't automatically a scam, but it should make you more careful, not less.
5. The VIN: Many sellers include it, and good ones will share it if asked. With the VIN you can check title and odometer history; the FTC points buyers to vehiclehistory.gov for that information, and says paid reports can add details like accident and repair history [1]. You can check for open safety recalls for free at NHTSA [2].
Questions to send the seller: (1) Is the title in your name, and is it clean? (2) Do you have maintenance records? (3) Why are you selling? (4) Any warning lights or known issues? (5) Can I have a mechanic inspect it? A seller's answers, and how quickly and clearly they give them, tell you a lot.
Red flags to walk away from: A salvage or rebuilt title that's only disclosed after you ask. A seller who won't share the VIN or let you get a pre-purchase inspection. A price that changes between messages. Pressure to pay a deposit before you've seen the car; Meta advises against deposits on cars until you've confirmed they're real [3]. A seller who can't meet where the car is.
When you see the car: Bring the listing with you and compare. Check that the VIN on the dashboard and door jamb matches the title and history report. Start the car cold if you can, and test everything that's mentioned in the listing. Consumer Reports recommends a mechanic's pre-purchase inspection and calls it always worth the $100 to $150 [4].
FAQ: How many photos is enough? There's no magic number, but you should be able to see every side of the car, the interior and the odometer. Is a missing VIN a dealbreaker? Not in the listing itself, but a seller who refuses to share it when asked is. Should I trust a listing that says "no lowballers"? It just means the seller has a firm idea of their price. Make a fair offer based on what similar cars sell for.
Where Deelz helps: Deelz watches Facebook Marketplace, Craigslist and OfferUp for your saved car searches by make, model, year, mileage, price and location, and emails you matches automatically as they're found. You get time to read the listing carefully and ask these questions before other buyers do. It's free during beta.
Sources
- [1]What to know when buying a used car online — FTC Consumer Alert (Jul 2024)
- [2]Check for Recalls — NHTSA
- [3]About scams on Facebook Marketplace — Meta Help Center
- [4]Consumer Reports' Used Car Checklist — Consumer Reports (updated Mar 2026)
